I absolutely love this store. I first found Pentagram during a trip to Salem last October (of course!) and ended up going back several times — it became a favorite stop. My whole family had readings and they were all amazing. When I came back to Salem this past May, I made a point to return, and it still felt just as supportive and grounded. The space has such a calm, welcoming energy — you can tell the owners and staff really care about creating a place where people feel held and seen. Amy is a gem — super insightful, detailed, and so kind. Her reading with my husband was spot on, and now she’s our go-to every time we’re in town. We love chatting with her. And Leanne, who owns the store, gave me a beautiful reading that left me feeling truly grounded. She has such a calming presence and offered clarity and wise guidance on things I was navigating. Her energy is the kind that stays with you. Pentagram is more than just a shop — it’s where the vibes are high and the veil is thin, in the best way. Can’t wait to go back again.

I recently visited Salem during April, and this store easily became my favorite out of all of them. These people KNOW THEIR STUFF and it is clear in the items they procure, offer, and the book section is always a give away as well. I LOVED IT. I even found a Hekatean Triangle for my sorcery! Also the shrines to Persephone and Poseidon were absolutely lovely and it was amazing little touch to have the Orphic hymns framed by the shrines. I was able to pause my shopping to offer prayers to them both (I’m a Hellenic Polytheist). If I make it back to Salem this will be my first stop! And I’m definitely going to be using their online website in the future as well. This shop is so appreciated

Visited Pentagram over the weekend after two different locals recommending the spot for a mediumship reading. I booked same day with Chris and am very grateful for my experience! The reading was personal, specific, and very moving for me personally. She has a beautiful gift, and anyone with an open heart and mind would benefit from a reading with her. Looking forward to visiting again in the future, thank you!